Test Anxiety Starts Long Before Test Day. Here's What Helps.

New research suggests that test anxiety may affect students more during preparation than during the exam itself. Learn why common study habits can make anxiety worse, and how students can prepare more effectively for the SAT, ACT, and other important exams.

 
Teen studying at a kitchen table with a laptop and practice test, looking focused

For many students, the prospect of taking a high-stakes exam like the SAT or ACT brings a familiar set of worries: What if I freeze? What if I forget everything I've studied? What if my nerves get the better of me?

It's natural to assume that anxiety interferes with test performance. But recent research challenges that conventional wisdom. According to psychologists Alex Jordan and Ben Lovett, the most significant effects of test anxiety may occur not during the exam itself, but in the weeks and months leading up to it.

Their argument has important implications for how students study, how parents support them, and how educators approach test preparation.

Does Test Anxiety Really Hurt Test Scores?

Most students have experienced some nervousness before an important exam. But does that nervousness actually prevent them from demonstrating what they know?

This may happen significantly less than we think.

In their recent Education Week article, Jordan and Lovett point to research suggesting that the relationship between anxiety and test performance is weaker than commonly assumed.

One particularly interesting study followed 309 medical students preparing for a licensing exam. Although more anxious students initially appeared to perform somewhat worse, the relationship disappeared once researchers accounted for differences in their knowledge before the exam. In other words, the anxious students weren't necessarily forgetting more of what they had learned. They may simply have learned less during their preparation.

The SAT itself offers another clue. In a classic 1962 study published by ETS, students performed the same on SAT sections that counted toward their official scores as on sections they knew didn't count. Raise the stakes or remove them, and the same preparation produced the same results.

This distinction is important. If anxiety primarily affects how students prepare, then improving their study habits may be more effective than focusing exclusively on relaxation techniques.

How Anxiety Can Lead to Ineffective Studying

Why might anxious students learn less during their preparation? One explanation involves the tendency to avoid uncomfortable tasks.

Effective studying requires students to confront what they don't know. Unfortunately, discovering gaps in one's knowledge can be stressful, particularly when an important exam is approaching.

As a result, anxious students may gravitate toward activities that feel productive but require relatively little effort:

  • Rereading textbook chapters or class notes

  • Highlighting important passages

  • Reviewing completed problems and their solutions

  • Watching explanations without attempting problems independently

These activities aren't necessarily useless. But they can create a misleading sense of mastery.

Consider a student preparing for the SAT Math section. After watching a tutor solve several quadratic equations, the student might feel confident that they understand the material.

But what happens when that same student encounters a new quadratic equation without any guidance?

Understanding someone else's solution is not the same as being able to produce one independently. The student may discover that the material isn't nearly as familiar as it seemed to them.

Unfortunately, students who find this experience stressful may avoid it altogether, reinforcing a cycle of ineffective preparation and increasing anxiety. Research has found that test-anxious students quiz themselves less and complete fewer practice problems, which feeds a cycle of shallow preparation and rising anxiety. That cycle can be especially sticky for students with ADHD or other executive function differences, for whom starting a blank problem is often the hardest step.

Why Practice Testing Is So Important

One of the most effective ways to improve learning is through retrieval practice: attempting to recall or apply information without looking at notes or solutions.

Instead of rereading a chapter, a student might close the textbook and explain its main ideas from memory. Instead of reviewing completed math problems, the student might work through unfamiliar problems independently.

This process can feel more difficult than passive review. But that difficulty is often precisely what makes it valuable.

Retrieval practice accomplishes two important things. First, it strengthens students' ability to recall information and apply what they've learned. Second, it reveals weaknesses that might otherwise remain hidden until test day.

For students preparing for the SAT or ACT, full-length practice exams offer an additional benefit: they provide opportunities to apply knowledge and test-taking strategies under realistic conditions.

Students can become familiar with the timing and structure of the exam, identify recurring mistakes, and gradually gain confidence in their ability to handle challenging questions.

The objective isn't simply to take as many practice tests as possible. It's to use those tests to identify specific areas for improvement and develop a more effective study plan.

Why Confidence Isn't Always a Reliable Measure of Preparation

One persistent challenge of test preparation is that students aren’t always good judges of how well they’ve mastered the material. Reviewing familiar problems can create a reassuring sense of competence, even when students haven't developed the ability to solve similar problems independently.

At the same time, more effective forms of studying can leave students feeling less confident at first. Working through unfamiliar questions without assistance is likely to expose gaps in understanding that passive review might have concealed. Although this experience can be discouraging, it also provides valuable information about what students still need to learn.

A related problem arises when students attribute disappointing practice test scores to anxiety. While nervousness can certainly interfere with performance, a closer examination of their mistakes may reveal more specific difficulties: a math concept they haven’t fully mastered, a question type they haven't practiced sufficiently, or a strategy they struggle to apply under actual time constraints.

For anxious students, that scrutiny can itself be uncomfortable. It's tempting to glance at the correct answers and move on rather than confront the reasons for each mistake. Yet careful review is where some of the most significant improvement takes place.

The important distinction is between feeling prepared and actually being prepared. Effective studying doesn't always produce an immediate sense of confidence. Sometimes, it begins by revealing weaknesses that students can then work systematically to overcome.

What Can Parents Do to Help?

Parents naturally want to reassure students who feel nervous about an upcoming exam. But according to Jordan and Lovett, telling students to relax may unintentionally reinforce the belief that anxiety must disappear before they can perform well.

A more productive approach is to help students recognize that feeling anxious doesn't necessarily mean they're unprepared or incapable.

Here are several ways parents can help:

  1. Encourage Consistent Preparation. Rather than waiting until the weeks immediately preceding an exam, encourage students to establish a manageable study schedule. Consistent preparation provides opportunities to identify and address weaknesses without the pressure of an approaching deadline.

  2. Emphasize Active Learning. Ask students to explain concepts without consulting their notes, work through unfamiliar problems, and review mistakes carefully. These activities may initially feel less comfortable than passive studying, but they provide a much clearer picture of what students actually know, and offer a more reliable path towards mastery of the relevant skills and content.

  3. Treat Mistakes as Useful Information. A disappointing practice test score isn't necessarily a setback. It can reveal the specific concepts, question types, or strategies that deserve additional attention. When students begin to view mistakes as opportunities for improvement rather than evidence of failure, challenging practice becomes less intimidating.

  4. Normalize Some Degree of Anxiety. Students don't need to feel perfectly calm to perform well. Mild or moderate nervousness is a normal response to an important challenge, and students can learn to work effectively despite it. Of course, students experiencing severe or persistent anxiety may benefit from additional support from a qualified mental health professional. But cultivating comfort with ordinary levels of anxiety is a skill that prepares students not only for test day, but for life.

Final Thoughts: Better Preparation Builds Confidence

The research Jordan and Lovett present offers an encouraging perspective on test anxiety: students don't necessarily need to eliminate their anxiety to succeed. They need to develop the knowledge, skills, and habits that allow them to perform effectively even when they're nervous.

For students preparing for the SAT, ACT, or other high-stakes exams, this means emphasizing consistent studying, independent problem-solving, and realistic practice tests.

Confidence is important, but it doesn't have to come first. Often, confidence develops through the experience of confronting difficult material, making mistakes, and gradually improving.

At North Avenue Education, our test preparation approach combines content mastery, test-taking strategies, and applied psychology to help students prepare effectively and build confidence. Our tutors use individualized study plans and practice test results to identify weaknesses, strengthen skills, and help students approach exams with greater confidence.

Interested in learning where your student stands? Explore North Avenue's SAT and ACT practice tests, or get started with a free full-length practice exam and score review.

 
Next
Next

A Tale of Two AP Students